Category Archives: CarletonDataJournalism2018_1

2017 Ontario Sunshine List reveals spike in taxable benefits in Windsor public school board

Share
The Greater Essex County District School Board’s administration office on Park Street West in downtown Windsor, Ont.(Screenshot from Google Maps).

A small group of upper-level employees in a southern Ontario public school board saw a massive spike in their taxable benefits in 2017, according to an analysis of the annual Ontario Sunshine List which discloses the salaries and taxable benefits of public sector employees who earned more than $100,000 in the past year.

Seventeen employees with the Greater Essex County District School Board (GECDSB) in Windsor, Ont. received between $50,000 and $76,000 in the year in taxable benefits, 33 times more than the other employees on the list.

Out of the top 10 public sector employees who received the highest taxable benefits last year, eight of these spots are occupied by GECDSB employees. To put things into perspective, the employee from a different school board on the list who received the next highest taxable benefit sat at around $23,000.

For these 17 employees, the taxable benefits received were equal to between 26 and 33 per cent of their salary paid, according to an analysis of the data. For the remaining employees, their taxable benefits received were equal to at or below 1.2 per cent of their salary earned, the analysis also showed.

Carleton University business and taxation professor Rebecca Renfroe. (Courtesy Sprott School of Business).

In the previous three years, all taxable benefits for employees of the GECDSB sat below a two per cent equivalency rate in relation to salary earned.

“Taxable benefits are any benefit you get as an employee by virtue of working for your employer,” explained Rebecca Renfroe, a business and taxation professor at Carleton University. “Just the fact that you work there means you get [receive this benefit] and if you didn’t work there you wouldn’t get it.”

These can range from things vehicle, parking or travel expenses to life insurance and retirement plans, she added.

According to Scott Scantlebury, public relations officer with the GECDSB, this sudden jump in taxable benefits for seventeen employees was caused by retirement plans.

Scantlebury declined an interview request, but in an emailed response he said that due to a one-time “settlement of post-retirement benefits for eligible non-bargaining unit staff” allowing “the GECDSB to eliminate a large, future, unfunded liability” taxable benefits were higher than normal.

Scantlebury said the settlement saved the school board approximately $16.7 million in future cost.

The taxable benefit was about $4.6 million, Scantlebury said, about $1 million of which appears on the 2017 Sunshine List. According to Scantlebury, the remaining $3.6 million was received by staff who do not make the list.

“The non-bargaining employees group is much larger than just senior administration,” he said. “Most staff who received this taxable benefit were not listed … as their salary does not eclipse the $100,000 threshold.”

Contributions made by employers to an employee’s registered retirement saving plans (RRSPs) are considered to be a taxable benefit, according to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA).

Hayden Kenez, press secretary with the Treasury Board of Ontario, said in an email that a breakdown of taxable benefits is not covered within the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, which governs the Sunshine List.

Carleton University’s Rebecca Renfroe spoke to the importance of a publicly accessible and searchable Sunshine List.

“It’s our money, it’s transparency. I think particularly in today’s world where the trust between public institutions and the public isn’t always where it should be … it’s important things like this exist so there is some level of transparency,” she said.

According to the GECDSB’s website, the board is home to 55 elementary schools and 15 secondary schools.

The Sunshine List has been in existence since 1997 and requires all public sector organizations to make public the names, position titles, salaries and taxable benefits received by employees making over $100,000 by Mar. 31 of each year.

(A map of all elementary [blue] and high schools [red] in the Greater Essex County District School Board [GECDSB] appears below.)

Criminal Activity of Cannabis Related Crimes and Youth Decreased by Half

Share

According to the Incident-Based Crime Statistics Database, cannabis crimes associated with youth decreased by half in the last five years in Ontario.

The majority age associated with cannabis production, trafficking and distribution is between 12 to 21 in Canada. By 2017, the rates of cannabis-related criminal activity committed by youth and adults was almost equal.

In Ontario, the crime rate for youth cannabis crimes dropped to 15.27 in 2017. In 2013, the rate was 37.45.

Despite this decrease, charges were laid on youth three times more than adults. However, these numbers do not include juveniles who were not charged.

In October, people who are nineteen and older will have legal access and possession of cannabis. It will still be illegal to sell cannabis to adolescence.

However, experts and substance and health specialists predict youth will be more open to discuss using cannabis to get the help they need.

Eugene Oscapella, a professor of criminology at the University of Ottawa, says drug policy is a human rights and justice issue.

“We are taking people, we’re stigmatizing them, we’re criminalizing them, we’re impairing their ability to earn a living, we’re impairing their ability to travel, we’re intruding their privacy and their private behavior, so there’s all sorts of human rights issues involved,” says Oscapella.

Oscapella says most pot sales are made by juveniles. The common age of first using cannabis is 16 or 17, and the heaviest consumption is between 15 to 24.

He adds there will be a reduction of some parts of crime one cannabis becomes legal, but there will still be a black-market targeting youth. However, he adds they will not likely be accessing cannabis through typical organized crime.

The Wellness Centre has access to a list of resources for counselling for substance abuse and mental health. Fa’Ttima Omran referred to the Amethyst Women’s Addiction Centre and the Distress Centre Ottawa for cannabis addiction. Photo by Katie Jacobs.

“It might be somebody’s older brother going into a store and buying cannabis … and selling it to younger kids and taking a small profit,” says Oscapella.

Oscapella says the most fundamental solution is to understand why people use drugs, why do some use it in a problematic way, and how do we help them.

Health specialists, such as Jessica Brett, a nurse at Ottawa Public Health (OPH) for three years, is working on putting together public education and policy analyses in preparation for legalization.

She says OPH supports legalization, specifically using regulations for the public’s best interest in health.

Brett says that criminalizing cannabis leads people, particularly youth, to experience social harms.

“Legalizing … hopefully will be able to address negative effects associated with cannabis use and hopefully minimize those social harms that we currently see,” says Brett.

Brett adds OPH will be encouraging youth under the age of 25 not to use it since it can change functions of the brain during adolescence, and can lead to mental health problems.

Fa’Ttima Omran, a second-year master’s student in legal studies, says with legalization, there may be more opportunities to have interesting discussions on cannabis addiction.

“There is a climate of change that … is making sure that individuals that are very vulnerable will not get caught up in the criminal justice system just because of their usage,” says Omran.

Omran is the administrative coordinator of the Wellness Centre at Carleton University. She says it’s more important to understand the social, political and mental health aspects behind cannabis use rather than criminalizing the person.

“People do seek counselling for using alcohol, for using all different substances, and it just brings into the conversation what addiction has within our society …and making sure that people that are experiencing that feel they are supported in any way possible in the most non-judgmental ways,” says Omran.

Omran says the Wellness Centre is designed to be a safe, non-judgmental space where information is confidential. The centre also has access to counselling resources outside the University.

Cannabis in Crimes Canada- Working Copy

Biggest hike of post-secondary tuition fees for international students found in Newfoundland and Labrador

Share

Newfoundland and Labrador had the highest rate of increase of university tuition fees for international students from the 2017/2018 to 2018/2018 academic year, but the province still has the lowest fees in the country, according to an analysis of Statistics Canada data that uses to track tuition fees.

The increase of tuition fees was a response to cuts in government funding for Memorial University of Newfoundland (MUN)’s operation budget in 2015, said Sofia Descalzi, the Canadian Federation of Students’ provincial chairperson.

New international students in Memorial University of Newfoundland (MUN) paid at least 28 per cent more than those enrolled in the years before. Despite the increase for new students, tuition fees for students who were enrolled before fall 2018 will not increase until 2021.

David Sorensen, the university’s communications manager, said the government has provided additional grant money to cover tuition increase for any domestic students but not for international students.

“While we have experienced budget reductions for several years, we have focused these as much as possible on the administrative side of the university,” he said.

Christine Neill, an economics professor at Wilfrid Laurier University who studies tuition fees, said provinces usually don’t fund universities for each international student in universities like they do with domestic students.

“For domestic students, someone in their family or themselves is usually paying taxes in order to provide support for government revenues in the province. In the case of international students, they don’t,” she said.

Neill also said international students are not part of the government’s constituents. This means the government doesn’t have to provide the same services to international students as they do with their constituents.

While the province saw a spike in tuition fees from last year, the province still has the lowest tuition fees in the country.

International students, Neill said, usually are less affected by tuition fee increase.

“People who are studying internationally don’t, in general, come from low-income families. The evidence suggests that if they think quality of the education is good enough, they can afford that,” she said.

Descalzi said the tuition fee increase for international students isn’t fair.

Sofia Descalzi, the chairperson of Canadian Federation of Students in Newfoundland and Labrador.
Photo Credits: Sofia Descalzi

“International students already pay an exorbitant amount for the same education than other students,” she said. “International students should not be bearing the cost of education down to their shoulders because of the decisions the provincial government has made.”

With the tuition fee increase, Neill said, international students will try to look for other ways to support themselves.

“Based on my research, people do try to increase their hours of work in response to tuition fee increase. It might mean that they will try to find employment at higher rates than they would otherwise,” she said.

Despite the increase of tuition fees for international students, Sorensen said, the university has increased services for international students like the renovation of the university’s Internationalization Office.

“We’ve had some budget challenges, but we’re making sure students are getting the best support possible,” Sorensen said. “In the next few months, the international office will be moving from its current location to a renovated space and will expand programs to adapt to the needs of current students – not only international students but the needs of local students to gain intercultural competence.”

Ottawa Annual Road Safety Report Reveals Most Fatal Injuries Occur in Young Adults

Share

The number of fatal injuries from traffic accidents is highest in 24 year olds, according to an analysis of the Government of Canada’s Annual Road Safety Report from 2014 to 2017.

Since Ottawa is a city that has three major post-secondary institutions, young adult residents are worried about what this means for the future of their driving.

On Nov. 14th, 2017 around 5:30 p.m., Hannah Anderson’s car was rear ended at the intersection of Bronson Avenue and Kippewa Drive. Anderson was 21 years old at the time.

“I ended up rear-ending the car in front of me because of the impact my car faced,” she said.

Anderson (left) with her younger sister Hunter (right), who was a passenger in her car during the accident. Photo courtesy of Hannah Anderson

 

Just two weeks earlier to Anderson’s accident, the Ottawa Police Service released a statement saying, “the Gatineau Police Service and Ottawa Police Service’s Selective Traffic Enforcement Program (STEP) will focus on red light running and stop sign violations during the month of November.”

STEP is implemented under the Safer Roads Ottawa program, which aims to reduce collisions on Ottawa’s roads, raise public awareness of road safety issues, integrate the work of City departments responsible for road safety, and improve communication, cooperation and collaboration among road safety agencies, according to the Ottawa Police Service.

“Intersections during rush hour are always a scary place to drive through, but traffic controls do seem to help with accidents,” said Anderson.

The now 22-year-old is currently working in Alberta and says the province uses photo radar for speed, red lights, crosswalks, and school zones.

“These extra precautions are helpful to catch dangerous drivers and in correcting their bad habits which can cause collisions,” she said.

Ontario is working towards creating new opportunities to help drivers combat unnecessary collisions and establish safer roads for both drivers and pedestrians.

“Ottawa residents have identified traffic safety as a top priority. The Safer Roads Ottawa Program is committed to using available resources to make Ottawa roads safer for residents,” said the Ottawa Police Service.

Although the Ottawa Police Services’ goal is to increase road safety for Ottawa’s citizens, there is still a lot that needs to be done to help those affected by past collisions heal from the trauma.

“I was scared to get behind the wheel of a car and it took a lot of courage to finally get my driver’s license,” said Alexandria Ouellette.

Ouellette was in the passenger seat of her mother’s car when it was hit by a truck which sped through a red light.

“The car completely flipped over, we were lucky to only leave with a few bruises and cuts from the glass but the fear I felt remained for a long time,” she said.

As the city continues to progress and move forward with extra precautions like STEP and encouraging residents to regularly report accidents, the idea of safer roads being implemented encourages young drivers to come to terms with their experiences.

“I had to do several weeks of physiotherapy to help with my injuries, and the amount of stress I felt was overwhelming, but I am learning to be more confident in my driving again,” said Anderson.

“I’m a lot more careful driving in rush hour now, but as careful as I am I don’t have the ability to control other drivers.”

The number of fatal injuries as a result of traffic accidents in Ottawa has increased by 45 per cent since 2015.

“As hard as we try, accidents can’t be eliminated. It’s from human error that they start and the only way it can be helped is if the city takes precautions,” said Ouellette.

Climate change affecting severity of tornadoes in Ontario, but not frequency

Share

 

The number of tornadoes considered disasters is on the rise, according to an analysis of data used by Public Safety Canada.

The Canadian Disaster Database contains detailed disaster data for over 1000 events since 1900 that have had a significant impact on the area that it occurred in. Examples include flooding, winter storms, and pandemics.

In order for an event to be considered a disaster, it needs to fall under one of the listed criteria, which include: 10 or more people killed, 100 or more people affected, injured, or homeless, an appeal for national or international assistance, and more.

Ontario currently has 19 tornadoes listed in the database, and the tornadoes that ripped through the Ottawa-Gatineau region on September 22 are likely to join the list.

“There are currently over 100 families that are without a home following a path of destruction that occurred in just a few moments,” said Mayor Jim Watson at a September 26 City Council meeting, adding: “it is heartbreaking to see.”

By Public Safety Canada’s standards, this would qualify it to make the list as more than 100 people have been left homeless. More than 30 homes in the Dunrobin area will require complete demolition, according to Mayor Watson, with more expected following inspections.

The number of tornadoes listed as disasters in the database has increased by 200 per cent in the last decade. While the 2000s saw a total of two events, so far there have been four events since 2010.

But don’t be so quick to assume it is a matter of climate change, stresses Dr. Jason Mah, who teaches natural disasters at Carleton University.

“There isn’t a direct link,” he said. “Climate change is impacting the water cycle. The natural disasters with the closest link to climate change are hurricanes.”

This is because hurricanes draw their power from warm ocean water, which is a direct result of climate change, he explained. Meanwhile, tornadoes are formed when a jet stream causes a collision of warm, moist air and cold air.

“There were 58 tornadoes in 2009, and 56 in 1980. It’s not exactly compelling evidence that there has been an increase in the number of tornadoes,” Dr. Mah said.

However, he did add that natural disasters occur around the world every day, “it’s just that we live in a very safe environment here in Canada.”

“These types of events are rare for the Ottawa region,” he said, adding that while the change in climate may not create more events; it may shift the regions that see large-scale tornadoes like the ones that get added to the Disaster Database.

Tornadoes are measured by the severity of an event based on estimating wind speed after assessing the damage caused, measured on the Enhanced Fujita (EF) Scale. Of the seven confirmed tornadoes in the Ottawa-Gatineau region, two measured at EF-03 according to The Weather Network.

According to Mayor Watson, there are no estimates on damages as of yet. However, when an EF03 tornado hit Goderich, Ont. in 2011, there was $130 million in damages, according to information from the Insurance Bureau of Canada website.

If the September 22 tornadoes are added to the Disaster Database, that will make it just the second tornado event to occur in September in recorded Ontario history, as well as the latest ever in a calendar year. The most popular time of year for tornadoes is between July and September, with the most incidents in the month of August.

While Ottawa recovers, officials are more focused on those efforts than they are concerned about this being added to the Disaster Database. “Ottawa is resilient, our city has always been resilient,” said Mayor Jim Watson.

A brief timeline of ‘disaster tornadoes’ in Ontario. Data from the Canadian Disaster Database.